First Division Award No. 24283 (Fletcher) (BLE/Chicago & Northwestern Trans.)

"However, in the circumstances present, discipline of dismissal is excessive. Claimant's service record indicates that in nearly twenty years of Carrier service he has only been disciplined one time previously."

First Division Award No. 24216 (Fletcher) (BLE/Burlington Northern RR)

"Carrier must consider the work record of Claimant prior to assessing discipline."

Special Board of Adjustment No. 910, Case No. 297, Award No. 297 (Peterson) (UTU/Consolidated Rail)

"In view of the particular circumstances of record, and in keeping with the spirit of the Co-Worker Referrals Agreement, we believe Claimant should be returned to service."